There’s a reason New York pizza is legendary. Walk into any pizzeria from Brooklyn to the Bronx, and you’ll hear the same promise: authentic New York-style pizza. But here’s the truth most people don’t want to admit—the vast majority of places claiming that title don’t actually deliver on it. Real New York pizza isn’t just about slapping some sauce and cheese on dough. There’s actual science behind that perfect slice, a delicate balance that takes years to master.
After 35+ years in the business, Mike at Wise Guys Pizzeria knows the exact formula—that precise equilibrium between crunch and chew, between structure and flexibility. It’s not guesswork. It’s not luck. It’s thousands of pizzas, constant refinement, and an unwavering commitment to getting it right every single time.
But here’s the thing most places get wrong: they think bigger is better, or more toppings mean more value, or that fancy ovens automatically make better pizza. They’re missing the entire point of what makes New York-style pizza special.
Let’s start with the fundamentals. New York-style pizza has specific characteristics that set it apart from every other regional style. It’s large—we’re talking 14-inch smalls, 16-inch larges, and 18-inch extra-larges—but those sizes aren’t arbitrary. They’re carefully optimized for the style itself, ensuring the right ratio of crust to topping across every slice.
The crust should be thin, but not cracker-thin. It needs structural integrity—when you fold that slice (and you should be able to fold it), it holds its shape. It doesn’t flop over like a sad handshake. It doesn’t crack like a chip. It bends, supports the weight of the toppings, and delivers that signature New York experience: walking down the street with a folded slice that doesn’t fall apart in your hand.
Mike’s signature approach, pulled straight from the menu, says it all: “Cheese pizza, thin, not too much sauce not too much cheese.” That balance is everything. Too much sauce and your crust gets soggy. Too much cheese and you lose the textural contrast that makes each bite interesting. The pizza becomes heavy, greasy, unbalanced. Real New York pizza respects proportions.
The crust itself should be crispy on the bottom with just enough char to add flavor, but the interior needs to maintain that characteristic chew. It’s a paradox that stumps most pizzamakers: how do you get something simultaneously crispy and chewy? That’s where decades of experience and understanding the science comes into play.
Mike’s approach to crust comes down to one phrase: “Trade secrets! It’s a very thin crust with just enough crunch and just enough chew.” Those words might sound simple, but they represent 35+ years of refinement. Every variable in pizza-making matters—fermentation time, dough hydration percentage, how you stretch the dough, even the humidity in the kitchen on any given day.
The bake time at Wise Guys is exactly 14 minutes to achieve that golden color crust. Why 14 minutes? Because underbake your pizza and you’re left with a doughy, underdeveloped base that can’t support the toppings. Overbake it and you’ve got cardboard—something that crunches when you bite it but offers no satisfying chew, no depth of flavor. Fourteen minutes is the sweet spot where the Maillard reaction occurs properly, where sugars caramelize, where the crust develops both color and flavor.
Mike uses a standard oven—not wood-fired, not a fancy brick oven—and that choice is deliberate. Consistency matters more than theater. A standard oven, when properly calibrated and operated by someone who knows exactly what they’re doing, delivers repeatable results. Every pizza that comes out should meet the same exacting standards, whether it’s 11 AM on a Tuesday or 8 PM on a Saturday.
The dough process itself involves carefully controlled fermentation that develops flavor and texture. The hydration percentage determines how the dough handles, how it bakes, how the crust develops those characteristic air pockets. Too wet and the dough won’t hold its shape. Too dry and you get a tough, dense crust. Mike has spent decades dialing in these exact specifications, and while the precise numbers remain trade secrets, the results speak for themselves.
Every variable compounds. Temperature interacts with timing. Dough thickness affects both. The way you distribute toppings changes how heat moves through the pizza. After 35+ years, Mike has internalized all of these factors. It’s become muscle memory, but it’s muscle memory built on a foundation of deep understanding.
“14 min—golden color crust.” That’s Mike’s benchmark, but it’s not just about watching a timer. After thousands of pizzas, Mike can tell if a pie is ready just by looking at it. That golden color isn’t merely aesthetic—it’s a visual indicator that the chemical reactions necessary for proper flavor development have occurred.
When the crust reaches that perfect golden hue, it means the starches have gelatinized, the proteins have set, and the Maillard reaction has created those complex, savory flavors that make pizza crust so satisfying. It’s where science meets the kind of intuition that only comes from 35 years of standing in front of an oven, watching pies transform from raw dough into perfect pizzas.
This is the difference between someone following a recipe and someone who truly understands the craft. The recipe tells you what to do. Experience tells you when it’s actually done.
At Wise Guys, there’s a non-negotiable standard: “We look at every pie or item before it leaves the shop to make sure it looks delicious.” This isn’t just about food safety or making sure the right toppings are on the pizza. This is about Mike’s personal standards for what constitutes an acceptable product.
Every pizza is inspected before it goes out the door. Is the crust the right color? Is the cheese evenly melted? Are the toppings distributed properly? Does it look like something you’d be proud to serve? Because Mike’s philosophy is crystal clear: “This is my way or the highway. 35 plus years in the business, I know how to make this work!”
That might sound uncompromising, but that’s exactly the point. Those decades of experience mean Mike knows EXACTLY what right looks like. A pizza that doesn’t meet standards doesn’t leave the kitchen, period. There’s no “eh, it’s close enough.” Close enough isn’t good enough when your reputation is built on consistency.
This level of quality control extends beyond just appearance. It’s about respecting the customer enough to ensure that every pizza they receive reflects the same standard Mike would accept for himself. Presentation matters. A pizza that doesn’t look perfect won’t taste perfect, and Mike’s not interested in sending out anything less than his best.
Understanding New York-style pizza means understanding what it’s not. It’s not Chicago deep dish with its thick, buttery crust and layers of cheese and sauce. It’s not Neapolitan pizza with its puffy, leopard-spotted crust and minimal toppings. It’s not the thin, cracker-crust tavern-style pizza you find in the Midwest.
New York-style is about balance and proportion at a scale that works for the lifestyle. You should be able to fold it, walk with it, eat it on the go. It’s designed to be practical—large slices that provide a complete meal, a crust that’s substantial enough to hold everything together but not so thick it becomes the dominant flavor.
But here’s the critical point: it shouldn’t be floppy. Proper New York pizza has backbone. When you pick up a slice, it shouldn’t immediately bend into a U-shape. The structure should support itself at a comfortable angle until you fold it—and that fold is a choice, not a necessity born from structural failure.
The sauce-to-cheese ratio is critical to maintaining this balance. Too much of either component overloads the crust and destroys the harmony that makes New York pizza special. Mike understands that every element needs to work in concert—the crust providing structure and flavor, the sauce adding acidity and moisture, the cheese contributing richness and binding everything together.
Three pizzas define what Wise Guys is all about, and each one tests different aspects of the craft. First, there’s the Cheese pizza—thin, not too much sauce, not too much cheese. This is the ultimate litmus test for any pizzeria. With nowhere to hide behind elaborate toppings, a cheese pizza reveals everything about your technique. The quality of your ingredients, the balance of your ratios, the perfection of your crust—it’s all exposed. If you can’t make a great cheese pizza, you can’t make great pizza, period.
Then there’s the Deluxe: “Everything but the kitchen sink!” This pizza proves you can handle complexity without losing the foundation. Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, bacon, onions, green peppers, olives, extra cheese—that’s a lot of weight and moisture to manage. A lesser pizzamaker would end up with a soggy middle or burnt edges. Mike’s crust stands up to the challenge, maintaining its structure and providing the perfect base for all those toppings.
Finally, the White Pizza—a delicious mozzarella ricotta cheese pizza that proves you understand cheese balance without relying on sauce. This is about understanding how different cheeses behave in the oven, how ricotta’s moisture content affects the bake, how to achieve richness without heaviness. It’s a completely different skill set from sauce-based pizzas, and executing it properly requires deep knowledge of your ingredients and process.
Mike’s philosophy is straightforward: “We use the best locally sourced ingredients that we can get!” Quality ingredients are non-negotiable. Fresh mozzarella, high-quality pepperoni, locally sourced vegetables when available—these choices matter. But here’s what most people don’t understand: ingredients are only as good as how you use them.
You can buy the most expensive imported Italian tomatoes, the finest buffalo mozzarella, the premium extra-virgin olive oil, and still make a terrible pizza if you don’t know what you’re doing. Mike’s 35 years of experience means he knows exactly how much sauce to ladle, how much cheese to distribute, how to arrange toppings so they cook evenly without creating hot spots or soggy patches.
Premium ingredients in the hands of someone who doesn’t understand proportion and technique will always be wasted. But those same ingredients in the hands of a master who’s spent decades refining the craft? That’s where magic happens.
After five decades in the business—starting as a young boy working in his family’s deli back in the 1970s—Mike has refined the science of New York-style pizza to the point where it’s become muscle memory. That perfect thin crust with just enough crunch and just enough chew? It’s not luck. It’s not a secret family recipe handed down through generations. It’s thousands of pizzas, millions of tiny adjustments, constant refinement born from an obsessive commitment to getting it right.
When you order from Wise Guys, you’re not just getting a pizza. You’re getting the benefit of 35+ years of perfecting this craft. Every 14-minute bake time, every inspection before the pizza leaves the shop, every balanced ratio of sauce to cheese—it all adds up to what real New York-style pizza should be.
That’s the promise: authentic New York pizza made by a New York native who’s been doing this longer than most pizzerias have been in business. No shortcuts. No compromises. Just the real deal, made the right way, every single time.
Wise Guys Pizzeria
117 East Merritt Avenue, Merritt Island, FL 32953
321.305.4055
Ready to experience authentic New York-style pizza? Visit us Tuesday through Saturday from 11 AM to 9 PM, or Sundays and Mondays during football season from 11 AM to 8 PM. Call ahead for pickup or check our website for online ordering.
Discover a location near you with delivery or pickup options available right now.
321.305.4055