
Cheese tortellini in creamy Alfredo sauce. Includes side salad & garlic knots.
Meatball parm sub served with your choice of potato salad, macaroni salad, coleslaw, or pickle wedge.
Jumbo wings 75¢ each (minimum 12). Choose your flavor, served with blue cheese or ranch & carrots or celery.
Pastrami on rye with provolone, served with your choice of potato salad, macaroni salad, coleslaw, or pickle wedge.
Philly cheese steak with white American cheese, sautéed peppers, onions & mushrooms. Served with your choice of potato salad, macaroni salad, coleslaw, or pickle wedge.
No products in the cart.
Craving authentic New York-style pizza? Order your favorite pies, heroes, and Italian classics from our diverse menu. With over 35 years of experience behind every dish, we bring the taste of Arthur Avenue and the streets of NY straight to your table. Swift delivery or convenient pickup—your choice, our commitment to quality.
Choose how you want to enjoy your meal. We deliver within a 5-mile radius to ensure your food arrives hot and fresh, just the way Mike intended. Prefer to pick up? Stop by our Merritt Island location and experience the authentic Italian deli atmosphere. Either way, every order gets the same attention to detail.
Discover recipes perfected over 35 years, passed down from Mike’s uncle Tommy’s deli in the 1970s. From our signature thin-crust cheese pizza with just the right crunch and chew to our famous Goodfellas subs, every recipe is crafted the old-school way—no shortcuts, no compromises. This is real New York Italian, made by a NY native.

Cheese tortellini in creamy Alfredo sauce. Includes side salad & garlic knots.

Traditional Italian salad with salami, pepperoni, capicola, provolone, olives & roasted red…


Breaded eggplant topped with marinara and melted mozzarella, served with pasta. Includes…

Jumbo pasta shells stuffed with ricotta, topped with marinara & mozzarella. Includes…


Half-pound burger topped with melted Swiss, provolone & muenster cheese. Served with…

Half-pound burger topped with melted cheddar cheese, crispy bacon & BBQ sauce.…
Seating is limited at our Merritt Island location. For groups of 8+, please call ahead to reserve space. Planning something bigger? Check out our catering options for events of any size.
Submitting this form is a request, not a confirmed reservation. We’ll call or text you within 24 hours to confirm availability and lock in your table.
Super Bowl LX is a rematch 11 years in the making. The Seahawks and Patriots meet again on football’s biggest stage — and on Merritt Island, Wise Guys Pizzeria is ready with game day specials built for the occasion.
The smell of cured meats hanging from the ceiling. The sound of the slicer working through fresh mozzarella. The constant rhythm of customers calling out orders while bread bakes in the back. For a young Mike in the 1970s, working in his Uncle Tommy’s New York deli wasn’t just a job—it was the beginning of […]
There’s a reason New York pizza is legendary. Walk into any pizzeria from Brooklyn to the Bronx, and you’ll hear the same promise: authentic New York-style pizza. But here’s the truth most people don’t want to admit—the vast majority of places claiming that title don’t actually deliver on it. Real New York pizza isn’t just […]
No products in the cart.
Discover a location near you with delivery or pickup options available right now.